📅 Event Timeline: 2024 Feb 10
🚀 Published on: 2024 Feb 10
🔄 Updated on: 2026 Nov 19 11:03 PM
📰 source: medium

SwitchUpCB published "The Medium Staff Hates Me" on Medium.




The Medium Staff Hates Me

I ranked a story on the frontpage of Medium, but it got removed and my referral was ignored.

3002277770035372034.jpeg
🔗

Screenshot from Author on March 26, 2023 showing his story on the Frontpage of Medium

Imagine you have been writing on Medium for over a year.

In that time, you published stories in over 10 publications, were awarded Top Writer status in multiple topics, and acquired over 50,000 views on the platform.

But it doesn’t matter.

The Medium Staff Doesn’t Like Me

The screenshot above shows the frontpage of the Medium’s Top 6 ranked view, which is accessible at medium.com for logged-out users.

Yes. That is my story, “ Why I Rewrote It In Rust ”.

But the story didn’t last there very long.

What happened?

A Medium staff member removed the story from the frontpage.

You might think this is a bold claim. But I know what happened because I used my software development skills to check the story’s distribution status.

Let me explain.


Do you understand how the Medium algorithm works? I explain it at moneyonmedium.com.

Look, you can check that out later.

I’m giving you an overview of the algorithm right now, but don’t expect everything to be covered.

The Medium frontpage shows 6 stories ranked by the algorithmic score; the rest are placed there by a human via The Medium Staff Picks list.

How is the algorithmic score determined?

Your story’s algorithmic score is calculated from a formula involving the story read time, claps, etc.

And that calculation is not the same as the earnings calculation.

What is story distribution status?

Your story’s distribution status determines whether your story can be distributed on Medium’s Distribution Network.

3002277770035372035.jpeg
🔗

This information used to be published on my website for free, but now it’s at Money On Medium.

With this information, it’s time for a recap.

What happened to my story on the frontpage of Medium?

What does this status mean?

Since the story had been on the frontpage (i.e., curated), this updated status means a Medium staff member removed the story from Medium’s Platform Distribution Network.

The significance of this removal is that other stories’ algorithmic scores on the platform did not outrank the story’s algorithmic score to make it disappear from the frontpage. Instead, the story was removed from the frontpage by a human.

But Medium’s “disdain” for me doesn’t stop here.


First, some context.

Why I Rewrote It In Rust was published on Mar 25, 2023.

At that time…

I didn’t care much about the removal of my story.

I didn’t care much about writing on Medium, either.

I don’t write to be remembered. I write so I don’t forget.

So, when my story was removed from the frontpage, I moved on.

I didn’t even tell anyone about the “achievement”.

I did not care.


I was interested in a software development position at Medium because I had identified many changes the platform needed (listed in What Medium Is Missing).

People agreed with me, but most importantly, a Medium Staff member responded to the story almost instantly.

3002277770035372036.jpeg
🔗

Harris Sockel response to “What Medium is Missing”

What features were requested?

Let’s start with the features addressed by Medium.

3002277770035372037.jpeg
🔗

H2 Font Size

The Medium Staff said this styling issue of the second-level heading would take two months to fix.

That’s outrageous.

Let me put this timeline in perspective for you.

Medium’s H2 issue was a styling issue. So, there was a CSS file containing the definition, .h2 { font-size: whatever }, which had to be changed.

All Medium had to do was change that line to fix the problem.

Like, can you create a file on your computer, write a sentence, then save the file? Congratulations, you are qualified to solve this H2 styling issue in less time than a team of people earning six figures ($) to do it in 3 months.

But maybe it was hard to find the line!

No, it wasn’t.

If the problem is a “bug”, Google Chrome’s Developer Tools show you where everything is defined.

Now you understand why this timeline is outrageous.

And imagine that you can develop a website — but not its content — like moneyonmedium.com in one week. That makes the situation more outrageous, but why?

I’ll explain later. But for now, let’s get to the point…

THIS IS NOT A CHANGE THAT TAKES 3-MONTHS TO FIX!

3002277770035372038.gif
🔗

gozzammit!

Moving on.

Let’s list some features Medium never addressed.

3002277770035372039.jpeg
🔗

Audience Retention Graphs

3002277770035372040.jpeg
🔗

Better Notifications Management

3002277770035372041.jpeg
🔗

Table of Contents block

and some other stuff.

OK, whatever, time to see if Medium is hiring.


When I applied to Medium, my application got nowhere.

After some time, I investigated a few employees on Medium’s Site Reliability Engineering (SRE) team, which ensures the platform doesn’t go offline.

Here is what I found.

3002277770035372042.jpeg
🔗

Disclaimer: Information is outdated now.

And so, I thought, “I’m qualified to join Medium.”

Here is why.

The team members didn’t develop open-source software like me.

They just used the tools.

Some team members weren’t even doing anything: They had very few public commits.

I developed Open Source Software recognized by 300 people and in the programming language of the team’s tools, so I considered myself more qualified than them.

I didn’t say that to them, though.

And that’s an objective statement, not emotional.

So, I asked team members for a referral to Medium.

But I never heard back from them.

Would a referral from them have mattered? I’m not sure.


Let’s compare my story to someone like Sivan Hermon.

She is a Jewish Woman Ex-Googler.

And I am not pointing out her identified religion due to any hatred of Jews. I don’t hate Jews. Their networking skills are very good, which becomes relevant later.

Sivan Herman got laid off from Google after spending 10 years “adding emojis to Google Chats”, then published a story about it.

Her story hit the front page.

When I read Sivan’s story, my assertion was that it was too mediocre in terms of objective writing quality (i.e., grammar, structure, etc) and engagement (i.e., attention) to be ranked naturally. So, I did not believe that her story would hit the front page on its own accord.

And seriously? After 10 years, the most notable contribution was emojis in a chat software? Whatever.

When I call her story mediocre, it doesn’t mean the story is bad. It means the story isn’t good enough to be promoted on the frontpage of Medium compared to other stories on Medium (with respect to engagment, aka algorithmic score).

So, what happened?

Is my judgment wrong?

No.

During that time, Medium had been pushing changes to the platform under the guise of “promoting higher-quality writing”. But, the definition of “higher quality” is subjective.

What do I mean?

You tell me. What is the Best Song or Album?

And is rap, music?

In the same way that music quality can only be judged by the individual, story quality can only be judged by the individual, too. But in this case, the “individual” was Tony Stubblebine and his ARMY OF PRODUCT MANAGERS who run the Medium platform.

Now, I’m not saying that because it’s how I feel.

I’m saying that based on data I collected for the stories on Medium’s Staff Picks List, promoted on the frontpage of the Medium platform for logged-out users.

3002277770035372043.jpeg
🔗

You can purchase this data set from moneyonmedium.com

The significance of product manager topics (i.e., UX, Product, etc.) being more prevalent than any other topic can only be understood with knowledge of my Theory of Relatability. This theory asserts that people engage with content that relates to themselves.

Stories about product management relate to Medium product managers, so it’s no surprise that these stories are considered to be “high-quality” more often.

But this product manager bias doesn’t only occur in story curation.

Let’s use Medium’s technical topic pages, such as technology or programming, as examples.

The promoted lists on these topics are not related to the work of an independent technological contributor. For example, there are no curated lists about Open Source Software (e.g., LINUX) or even industry trends.

Instead, the promoted lists on these topics are about Apple PRODUCT MANAGEMENT, HIRING (independent contributors as a manager), and outdated information in a fast-moving industry.

So, Medium’s claim that it wants to push for “high-quality writing” is a misnomer. It’s a dog whistle for “pushing the writing I read and find relatable.”

Keep that in mind.


How did Sivan Herman get her first story on the front page of Medium?

Here is what happened.

She is a Jewish Woman Ex-Googler. That’s important because it means she is a “minority” and FAANG BOSS GIRL.

She posted in Better Programming, a publication by Tony Stubblebine, who claims to push the stories of “minority” writers.

And then her first story ended up on the front page for “millions” to read.

The significance is that Sivan Herman did not reach the frontpage on the merit of engagement or writing quality. Instead, she was admitted to the frontpage by networking with the CEO.

I was correct about that.

And it happened again recently, too.

That’s two stories curated on the front page of Medium.

Now, I’m not saying that my judgment is the be-all and end-all.

I’m not saying her stories aren’t engaging or high quality to others, but rather that they don’t hit the front page on that accord.

That’s an objective statement, not emotional.

I’m not saying my stories have no flaws, either.

But at least I can admit that my judgment isn’t universal, unlike Medium staff.

I could also go on right now about how the platform did not gain a surge in memberships due to recent changes in promoting “higher-quality” stories, but rather something else. However, I don’t want to get off-topic…

Besides, I wasn’t even going to release this story, but I decided to do so because it taught me a life lesson.

Here is that life lesson.


I used to be angry at how the Medium platform worked.

Authors like Sivan Herman gain their following on the merit of their network rather than the merit of their skills.

Authors like me must gain a following on the merit of objective engagement and marketing skills. My stories only succeed when they are engaging and deemed high-quality by others.

And most of the time, I must distribute them myself.

So, when my story hit the frontpage based on algorithmic score and then got removed by Medium staff, I realized my growth is being curbed.

This means I am doing more work for less reward, all because the Medium Staff decided not to be fair.

And that is a parallel that models my experience with the corporate world as a short black male “software developer”.

Studies show that I am more likely to be paid less and experience bias in my work due to my physical attributes.

And mathematically, I must work harder in every interview loop than my peers, as discussed in The Issue With Affirmative Action.

It doesn’t matter that I

When it comes to software development, I can’t get a job or be paid what I am worth.

My skill and the work I do doesn’t matter.

Why?

Because my physical attributes are not inherently selected in social situations.

Because my physical attributes are not inherently selected by a group of people.

Because being short and black means you are not inherently selected by a group of people.

And when a company is a group of people…

It’s not surprising that only 5% of the software industry is black.

But f*ck that diversity noise for a second.


Medium has decided to push for curation by a group of people.

Now, when I write on Medium, I am fighting the same battle I fought at school and wagie. That battle of fighting corporate bias which stems from racist policy and people who define what it means to be “qualified”.

3002277770035372044.jpeg
🔗

Careers at Medium.

Look at this motherf*cking picture!

I’ll never be qualified.

Not in their eyes.

But you know what?

That’s life.

Life isn’t fair.

People used to tell me that growing up.

I wouldn’t accept it because that’s not the expectation set by society.

What did the most leftist blogging platform on the internet teach me?

Get over it.

Expectations are fantasy.

This is reality.

Life Isn’t Fair.

I am grateful for the life lesson, Medium Staff.


Did you find insightful information about the Medium Algorithm and Distribution Network in this story? Find more insights that help you make money with your stories at Money On Medium.